Have you made these career-limiting mistakes with executive recruiters? Find out now...
29: Why You Don't Want to Reach Out to
29: Why You Don't Want to Reach Out to "an Executive Search…
In addition to reviewing key learnings from previous episodes on executive recruiters and executive search firms, Doug Lester helps you und…
Choose your favorite podcast player
The Career Narratives Podcast with Doug Lester
Jan. 17, 2025

29: Why You Don't Want to Reach Out to "an Executive Search Firm"

In addition to reviewing key learnings from previous episodes on executive recruiters and executive search firms, Doug Lester helps you understand how search firms are structured. Armed with this information, you'll be better equipped to build the long-term relationships with recruiters that can help advance your career.

In addition to reviewing key learnings from previous episodes on executive recruiters and executive search firms, Doug Lester helps you understand how search firms are structured. Armed with this information, you'll be better equipped to build the long-term relationships with recruiters that can help advance your career.

🎧 Take control of your narrative and advance your career — subscribe to the podcast!

🤔 Need a thought partner with experience as a Fortune 100 hiring manager, an executive recruiter at a top firm, and a coach at Harvard Business School? Schedule a Career Strategy Session with Doug

Avoid making 3 common mistakes with executive recruiters

📸 Improve your executive presence on Zoom

Chapters

00:09 - Introduction

01:47 - Recent Episodes on Executive Search

02:08 - Retained and Contingency Firms

03:04 - Who Do Executive Recruiters Work For?

03:25 - Five Ways to Get on Recruiters' Radar Screens

04:15 - Why You Don't Want to Reach Out to Recruiters Directly

04:42 - Why Recruiters Are So Risk-Averse

05:27 - How Executive Search Firms Are Structured

07:48 - How to Target the Right People in Search Firms

09:08 - Share This With a Friend and Sign Up for a Session with Doug

Transcript

WEBVTT

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:06.820
Over the past few episodes, we've taken a deep dive into the world of executive search firms and executive recruiters.

00:00:07.209 --> 00:00:20.179
And now, I want to review some of the not always obvious insights that came up in some of those episodes, and add something new that I think will fundamentally change how you think about working with search firms.

00:00:20.670 --> 00:00:27.140
But before I do that, let me share something that has happened in more coaching sessions than I can count.

00:00:27.690 --> 00:00:37.966
I'm on a call with a mid or senior-level executive, someone with great education, experience at market leading companies and a strong track record of success.

00:00:38.396 --> 00:00:46.256
Then, That person reports they're getting in touch with, and I'll put this in quotes,"search firms," trying to get their attention.

00:00:46.697 --> 00:00:55.837
When I ask which search firms, they can give me the names of firms but can't recall or don't yet have specific names of individual recruiters.

00:00:56.237 --> 00:01:00.926
And that's when I know we need to have a different kind of conversation.

00:01:01.466 --> 00:01:05.236
One about how executive search firms are structured.

00:01:05.602 --> 00:01:06.792
and really work.

00:01:07.191 --> 00:01:08.031
Stay tuned.

00:01:47.141 --> 00:01:57.572
Before I get into the main topic for this episode, how search firms are structured as a business, I'd like to summarize what we've covered in recent episodes about executive search.

00:01:57.992 --> 00:02:02.412
If you've listened to the episodes, this will be a helpful, I hope, reminder.

00:02:02.731 --> 00:02:07.522
And if you haven't, you can take a deeper dive by queuing up the episodes I'll be mentioning.

00:02:08.072 --> 00:02:22.062
So in Episode 25, we talked about a few fundamentals of the industry, specifically that there are two types of search firms, retained and contingency, and that they operate with very different economic models.

00:02:22.451 --> 00:02:29.421
Retained firms work exclusively for a client to fill a specific role, and they get paid a fixed fee to do it.

00:02:29.852 --> 00:02:38.102
As a result, they have a strong economic incentive to stay focused on their current searches and to close them quickly and efficiently.

00:02:38.532 --> 00:02:45.866
Contingency firms may have long term relationships with their clients, But they compete against other firms to fill open roles.

00:02:46.206 --> 00:02:53.537
As a result, they have an economic incentive to shop you around as a candidate to as many of their clients as possible.

00:02:54.086 --> 00:03:03.377
Chances are, if you're a listener of this podcast, you're going to want to work with the retained firms who typically fill the higher level, more desirable roles.

00:03:03.926 --> 00:03:17.467
In that same episode, Episode 25, I also covered a crucial point that many people are confused about retained executive recruiters don't work for you, they work for their clients, the people paying the bills.

00:03:17.967 --> 00:03:24.907
While they'll treat you ethically and professionally, the primary accountability is always going to be to their clients.

00:03:25.456 --> 00:03:31.056
In Episode 26, we discussed five key ways to get on recruiters radar screens.

00:03:31.387 --> 00:03:36.097
And those are, one, building a reputation for excellence, plain and simple.

00:03:36.546 --> 00:03:43.317
Two, staying connected with the people in your network who will ultimately refer executive recruiters to you.

00:03:43.866 --> 00:03:46.727
Three, sharing your narrative effectively.

00:03:46.993 --> 00:03:51.584
That's what you do, the context you do it in, and the impact of your work.

00:03:51.770 --> 00:03:54.379
Those are the basic things people need to know about you.

00:03:54.909 --> 00:03:59.080
Four, maintaining a complete and compelling LinkedIn profile.

00:03:59.469 --> 00:04:02.819
And five, being responsive to recruiters.

00:04:03.099 --> 00:04:04.610
even when you don't need them.

00:04:05.159 --> 00:04:14.629
Each of these approaches builds on the others to create a strong foundation for working with the executive recruiters who can be instrumental in advancing your career.

00:04:15.180 --> 00:04:24.860
In Episode 27, we talked about why reaching out cold to recruiters you don't know can actually hurt your chances of working with them.

00:04:25.110 --> 00:04:41.245
We explored how reaching out cold, that is without an introduction or referral, can lead you to being labeled as a"job seeker" in their database, a label that can raise red flags about you as a potential candidate in the firm's searches.

00:04:41.795 --> 00:04:48.925
And going back in time to Episode 14, I took a deep dive into why recruiters can be so risk-averse.

00:04:49.264 --> 00:05:05.560
I talked about the guarantee that most search firms offer to their clients, which is that if a placed candidate doesn't work out within the first year or some other contractually predefined period, the executive search firm may have to redo the search for free.

00:05:06.110 --> 00:05:15.600
This creates a powerful incentive for the recruiters to exhibit a bunch of risk-averse behaviors when they source and present candidates to their clients.

00:05:16.149 --> 00:05:26.480
So, being aware of your personal risk profile when it comes to engaging with recruiters and considering ways you might help ameliorate that risk is probably a good idea.

00:05:27.029 --> 00:05:40.860
With that review out of the way, I want to add something new into the mix that I think could change how you think about approaching executive search firms, and it's a fundamental misunderstanding I've seen among many of my clients.

00:05:41.389 --> 00:05:54.050
They believe their goal should be to get on the radar screens of executive search firms when they really need to be getting to know specific people in specific practice areas within those firms.

00:05:54.600 --> 00:06:00.430
You see, executive search firms aren't monolithic in the way most people often think about them.

00:06:00.930 --> 00:06:09.110
They're more like collections of specialized boutique search firms operating under one brand with a bunch of shared services.

00:06:09.579 --> 00:06:12.839
Think of them as businesses within businesses.

00:06:13.389 --> 00:06:20.370
Here's an example from my own experience at Isaacson, Miller, the executive search firm I was a senior associate at.

00:06:20.920 --> 00:06:23.170
We had specialized practice areas.

00:06:23.209 --> 00:06:29.269
In fact, we had someone who focused exclusively on head librarian searches.

00:06:29.569 --> 00:06:30.230
That's right.

00:06:30.779 --> 00:06:32.990
That was their entire focus.

00:06:33.360 --> 00:06:44.420
And I worked in the institutional advancement practice, focusing primarily on hiring chief development officers for nonprofits, members of their teams, and heads of alumni relations.

00:06:44.970 --> 00:06:51.060
So what does this mean for someone like you who might want to get on the radar screens at executive search firms?

00:06:51.610 --> 00:06:59.139
Let's say that I was still at Isaacson Miller, and you wanted to be considered for a chief development officer role through the firm.

00:06:59.670 --> 00:07:02.199
It's not enough just to target the firm.

00:07:02.569 --> 00:07:09.029
You needed to know or be known by the partner who led my practice, me or my associates.

00:07:09.410 --> 00:07:17.329
And if we didn't know you directly, you needed to know someone we knew or would likely reach out to for referrals in our searches.

00:07:17.879 --> 00:07:26.220
And let's say that you didn't know all this, and you happened to reach out to the person who ran the head librarian searches, because you didn't know any better.

00:07:26.769 --> 00:07:32.220
Well, I'm sure you can guess that you'd probably come across as a little out of the loop.

00:07:32.886 --> 00:07:48.002
This practice area structure combined with everything else we've discussed in previous episodes about executive search means that success with recruiters, executive recruiters that is, requires a much more focused approach than most people might assume.

00:07:48.435 --> 00:07:59.136
Instead of trying to get on the radar screens of firms, you need to first identify which practice areas in which firms are most relevant to your career goals.

00:07:59.685 --> 00:08:02.526
This might take some research and networking to figure out.

00:08:03.065 --> 00:08:10.016
Second, focus on building relationships with specific recruiters in those practice areas in those firms.

00:08:10.565 --> 00:08:13.036
Remember what we discussed in Episode 26?

00:08:13.386 --> 00:08:18.471
This happens primarily through referrals from people in the firm's existing network.

00:08:18.800 --> 00:08:21.591
Don't try to reach out directly if you can help it.

00:08:22.021 --> 00:08:35.000
And third, maintain those relationships over time by being responsive and helpful when recruiters you might be interested in working with someday reach out to you, even if you're not currently looking to move.

00:08:35.551 --> 00:08:44.770
As I covered in Episode 27, this long-term relationship building is far more effective than reaching out when you actually need something.

00:08:45.321 --> 00:08:49.900
Working effectively with executive recruiters is definitely a long game.

00:08:50.370 --> 00:08:56.370
One that's won through building relationships based on reputation, credibility and trust.

00:08:56.544 --> 00:08:59.495
It's not about quick fixes or mass outreach.

00:08:59.784 --> 00:09:07.154
It's about understanding how the business really works at the practice area level and aligning your approach accordingly.

00:09:07.705 --> 00:09:14.606
If you found this helpful, please share it with someone who could benefit from understanding how executive search firms really work.

00:09:15.549 --> 00:09:34.950
And if you're trying to figure out how to build relationships with the right recruiters in your industry, or you're currently a candidate in a search run by an executive search firm, consider signing up for a Career Strategy Session with me at careernarratives.com/strategy.

00:09:35.519 --> 00:09:37.039
See you in the next episode.